| 1 | Boring Process Compatibility | The machine should support the required process, such as gun drilling, BTA single-tube drilling, or ejector drilling. Process selection depends on bore diameter, depth-to-diameter ratio, material, and chip evacuation requirements. | Process description, tool-system specifications, sample parts, chip-control results, and application references for comparable materials. | A machine designed for the wrong deep-boring process can produce unstable cutting, poor chip evacuation, excessive tool wear, and unacceptable bore quality. | 15% |
| 2 | Bore Diameter and Drilling Depth | Capacity must cover the complete production range, including minimum and maximum bore diameter, maximum drilling depth, workpiece length, and depth-to-diameter ratio. Actual limits vary by machine configuration. | A dimensional capacity sheet showing bore range, drilling depth, workpiece envelope, spindle travel, and loading limits. | Nominal capacity alone is insufficient if the machine cannot process the longest, heaviest, or smallest-diameter production parts. | 14% |
| 3 | Accuracy and Surface-Finish Capability | Key acceptance characteristics include bore diameter tolerance, straightness, roundness, cylindricity, concentricity, and surface roughness. Required values must be defined by the part drawing and process plan. | Measured inspection reports from comparable parts, gauge details, calibration records, and documented acceptance criteria. | Deep bores can accumulate deviation over depth; verified process results are more reliable than catalog accuracy claims. | 14% |
| 4 | Machine Tool Accuracy Verification | Geometric accuracy and positioning performance should be verified using recognized machine-tool inspection practices, including applicable ISO 230 procedures or equivalent national standards. | Recent inspection reports, laser or ball-bar test results where applicable, compensation records, and a defined factory acceptance test. | Independent verification helps distinguish repeatable machine performance from unverified marketing specifications. | 10% |
| 5 | Spindle, Feed, and Coolant System | Suitable spindle speed, torque, feed force, coolant pressure, filtration, and flow are essential for stable deep-hole drilling. Required values depend on tool diameter, material, and cutting parameters. | Spindle torque curves, feed-force data, coolant pressure and flow specifications, filtration rating, tank capacity, and temperature-control options. | Insufficient torque, feed force, or coolant performance can cause tool deflection, overheating, premature tool failure, and poor hole quality. | 12% |
| 6 | Workholding and Part Handling | The system must safely support the workpiece throughout drilling. Important variables include chuck capacity, steady rests, fixture rigidity, maximum part mass, tailstock or support arrangements, and loading method. | Workholding drawings, maximum load data, fixture repeatability results, loading diagrams, and safety documentation. | Rigid, repeatable support reduces vibration, improves straightness, and protects operators and equipment during long drilling cycles. | 8% |
| 7 | Automation and Control Functions | Useful functions may include programmable feed control, tool-load monitoring, coolant monitoring, automatic chip management, probing, part measurement, recipe storage, and production data logging. | Control-system specification, available sensors, automation layout, software screenshots, cycle-time data, and integration interfaces. | Automation can improve consistency and reduce operator dependence, especially for repeat production and long unattended cycles. | 8% |
| 8 | Quality Management and Traceability | A documented quality-management system, commonly certified to ISO 9001, should cover design control, purchasing, production inspection, nonconformance handling, calibration, and corrective action. | Valid certificate, certificate scope, audit information, inspection plans, calibration records, and sample quality dossiers. | Traceability lowers commissioning risk and provides a structured response when machine or process issues occur. | 7% |
| 9 | Installation, Training, and After-Sales Support | Support should cover installation, alignment, operator training, preventive maintenance, spare parts, remote diagnostics, response times, and local or regional service availability. | Service-level agreement, response-time commitments, spare-parts list, training plan, escalation process, and installed-base references. | Downtime and commissioning delays can exceed the initial machine-price difference, making service capability a major ownership factor. | 7% |
| 10 | Total Cost, Delivery, and Compliance | Evaluation should include machine price, tooling, coolant equipment, installation, training, freight, duties, energy use, maintenance, spare parts, delivery schedule, safety requirements, and applicable electrical or regional regulations. | Itemized quotation, Incoterms, warranty terms, delivery milestones, utility requirements, risk assessment, safety declarations, and lifecycle-cost estimate. | A complete cost and compliance review prevents hidden expenses and reduces the risk of delays during installation, acceptance, or production launch. | 5% |