| 1 | Standards Compliance and Certification | 18% | Valid type-test reports, routine-test records, product certificates, technical drawings, and traceable model documentation. | IEC 60099-4 for metal-oxide surge arresters; GB/T 11032 for AC metal-oxide surge arresters; applicable project specifications. | Full compliance with the required standard, complete documentation, and independently verifiable test evidence. |
| 2 | Electrical Rating and Application Coverage | 12% | Available rated-voltage classes, continuous operating voltage, nominal discharge-current options, line-discharge classes, and system application range. | Comparison of nameplate data, datasheets, insulation coordination requirements, and purchaser specifications. | A clearly defined product range with correctly coordinated Ur and Uc values for the intended system voltage. |
| 3 | Lightning and Switching Energy Capability | 12% | Residual-voltage curves, current-impulse results, switching-current capability, thermal-energy test results, and discharge-class data. | IEC 60099-4 or GB/T 11032 test procedures, supported by laboratory reports for the specified arrester design. | Low and consistent protective levels combined with verified energy-handling capability for the target application. |
| 4 | Long-Term Leakage and Thermal Stability | 10% | Reference-voltage consistency, leakage-current trends, thermal stability results, accelerated aging data, and pressure-relief performance. | Routine and type-test procedures specified by IEC 60099-4 or GB/T 11032, including stability and aging evaluations. | Stable electrical characteristics after environmental and electrical aging, with controlled leakage-current behavior. |
| 5 | Zinc Oxide Varistor Disc Quality | 10% | Varistor-disc test records, lot traceability, nonlinearity data, reference-voltage distribution, defect-screening results, and incoming inspection procedures. | Supplier quality records, statistically controlled inspection plans, and sample verification against approved technical parameters. | Tight batch-to-batch uniformity, complete traceability, and documented screening of varistor elements. |
| 6 | Sealing and Environmental Resistance | 8% | Housing material, sealing structure, water-ingress resistance, pollution-performance data, UV resistance, temperature-cycle results, and altitude suitability. | IEC 60099-4 environmental and mechanical tests, plus enclosure and installation requirements for the project location. | Reliable sealing and insulation performance in humid, polluted, coastal, high-altitude, or high-temperature environments. |
| 7 | Manufacturing Quality Control | 10% | Process-control plans, production inspection checkpoints, calibrated equipment, nonconformance records, corrective actions, and final routine-test coverage. | ISO 9001-based quality systems, documented inspection procedures, and auditable production records. | Consistent production results supported by documented processes, calibration, traceability, and final inspection. |
| 8 | Testing Facilities and Technical Validation | 8% | In-house or qualified external laboratories, impulse-current capability, residual-voltage measurement, thermal testing, mechanical testing, and calibration status. | Laboratory competence, calibrated instruments, recognized test methods, and independently reviewable reports. | Strong validation capability with repeatable test results and clear separation between design verification and routine testing. |
| 9 | Customization and Project Engineering | 5% | Options for line and transformer applications, housing dimensions, mounting arrangements, terminal configuration, altitude, pollution level, and special grounding requirements. | Approved drawings, calculation sheets, interface specifications, and project-specific technical clarification documents. | Accurate engineering support and documented customization without compromising certified performance. |
| 10 | Delivery, Service, and Lifecycle Support | 7% | Typical lead time, spare-parts availability, warranty terms, installation guidance, failure-analysis capability, operating manuals, and after-sales response process. | Contract requirements, service-level commitments, warranty documentation, and historical delivery-performance records. | Reliable delivery and responsive technical support throughout installation, commissioning, operation, and maintenance. |
| Total Evaluation Weight | 100% | Use weighted scores to create a transparent Top 10 comparison |